All topics

Media & "fake news"

Who to trust when nobody trusts anyone.

“The mainstream media is all fake news.”

"Major news outlets are broadly unreliable and should not be trusted."

What's actually true

Major news outlets make mistakes and can frame stories selectively, but that doesn’t mean everything they report is fabricated. A factual report, an opinion column, and a cable-news argument aren’t the same thing. The strongest way to judge a story is to check its evidence, whether independent reporting supports it, and whether the outlet corrects errors.

Where they have a point

Sensational headlines, selective coverage, and real reporting failures give people legitimate reasons to be skeptical. Trust should be earned—not demanded because a familiar logo is on the screen.

Say this (15 seconds)

I get why you’re skeptical—news outlets do get things wrong. But ‘all fake’ goes too far. I’d rather check the specific story: what’s the evidence, and does it hold up?

Then ask

What would a news outlet need to do to earn your trust?

Sources

Pass the gravy (exit line)

Anyway, I’m ready to stop fact-checking the news and start investigating dessert.

“You can't trust anything, so I just do my own research.”

"Because information sources can be unreliable, researching things yourself is the best way to know what’s true."

What's actually true

No source is right about everything, but that doesn’t mean all sources are equally unreliable. Doing your own research can help when it means checking original evidence, comparing independent reporting, and looking for information that might change your mind. A source’s transparency, relevant expertise, and willingness to correct mistakes are better guides than whether its conclusion feels right.

Where they have a point

They’re right that institutions and news outlets make mistakes, and that headlines shouldn’t be accepted on faith. Wanting to check the evidence yourself is a good instinct; the challenge is applying the same scrutiny to sources you like.

Say this (15 seconds)

I’m all for checking things ourselves. I just wouldn’t put every source in the same bucket. I trust a claim more when I can check the evidence and other independent sources back it up.

Then ask

When two sources disagree, what helps you decide which one has the stronger evidence?

Sources

Pass the gravy (exit line)

Meanwhile, I’m ready to do some firsthand research on that pie.